New cases of abduction and coercion suggest the practice of coercive faith-breaking (deprogramming) is far from over
Part 1 of new 4-part series

See part 2: Convicted Pastor Leads Faith-Breaking Network
See part 3: Controversial Korea-Japan Faith-Breaking Ties
Recent abductions, confinement, and coercive de-conversion attempts suggest that a practice once condemned after a young woman’s death may be gaining new momentum.
See also From Media Label to Religious Persecution
The practice of forcibly breaking the faith [See editor’s note 1 below] of members of unpopular religious movements appears to be making a comeback in South Korea. According to new information presented by Italian sociologist of religion Dr. Massimo Introvigne, incidents involving abducting religious believers, confining them, and coercively breaking their faith [See editor’s note 1 below] have stopped declining and may now be increasing.
The issue is particularly concerning for members of Shincheonji [See editor’s note 2 below], the World Mission Society Church of God [See editor’s note 3 below], the Christian Gospel Mission (Providence) [See editor’s note 4 below], and other minority religious movements.

In an article published by Bitter Winter on 30th October 2026, Introvigne describes how a network of Protestant pastors, anti-cult activists, and lawyers in South Korea and Japan may be contributing to the renewed activity. He also points to a changing political climate that, in his assessment, has encouraged anti-cult activists to become more confident.
What is coercive deprogramming or faith-breaking? [See editor’s note 1 below] It is a practice in which adult members of religious movements are abducted, often by their own parents, and confined against their will until they agree to abandon their faith.
The process may involve isolation from friends and fellow believers, psychological pressure, threats, physical violence, and intensive religious instruction intended to make the individual renounce his or her religious convictions.
Although the practice originated in the United States, courts in North America and Europe largely brought it to an end before the close of the twentieth century.

Japan became one of the countries where it survived longest. More than 4,000 members of the Unification Church, now known as the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification, were reportedly subjected to such practices.
One particularly notorious case involved Toru Goto (後藤徹), who was confined for more than twelve years. In 2014, the Tokyo High Court held those responsible for his confinement liable, and Japan’s Supreme Court confirmed the decision in 2015. Following these rulings, coercive faith-breaking (deprogramming) [See editor’s note 1 below] in Japan largely ceased.
South Korea, however, followed a different path.
A tragic death that shocked the country
South Korean courts have sometimes punished pastors who directly participated in violent confinement. However, parents who locked up their adult sons and daughters after receiving advice from religious counsellors have frequently avoided prosecution. Police officers called to intervene have also sometimes treated such incidents as private family disputes.
One case brought international attention to the problem.
In December 2017, Shincheonji [See editor’s note 2 below] member Gu Ji-in (구지인) was abducted by her parents for the second time. She was taken to a remote accommodation facility, where her father bound and gagged her to prevent her escape.
She suffocated, was declared brain-dead, and died in January 2018.

Her death triggered widespread protests in South Korea and international criticism. Both the US Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) and the US Department of State subsequently addressed the issue.
The tragedy made deprogrammers (faith-breakers) more cautious, and the number of reported cases began to decline.
A disturbing reversal in the statistics

However, figures collected by human rights advocates connected with Shincheonji [See editor’s note 2 below] and shared with Bitter Winter suggest that this downward trend may have come to an end.
Between 1st January 2003, and 15th October 2026, the advocates documented 2,205 cases of coercive conversion involving Shincheonji members.
The annual number increased from just one recorded case in 2003 to 151 in 2013 and 179 in 2016.
After the death of Gu Ji-in (구지인), the figures fell to 131 in 2018 and 127 in 2019. There was a temporary increase to 191 cases in 2020, when Shincheonji [See editor’s note 2 below] was widely blamed in South Korea for the COVID-19 epidemic.
The subsequent decline continued, with 88 cases in 2022, 64 in 2023, 69 in 2024, and 57 in 2025.
But by 15th October 2026, another 55 cases had already been recorded.
The figures suggest that the decline has stopped, even though the year was not yet over.
Of the 55 victims documented in 2026, 42 were women and 13 were men. Seventeen people, or approximately 31 percent, were physically confined. Twelve of those confined were women, and twelve were in their twenties.
Restrictions on communication were reported in 52 cases. These included confiscated mobile phones and isolation from friends and fellow believers. Verbal abuse was also reported in 52 cases.
Among the locations identified by victims was a guesthouse owned by a Protestant church. According to their accounts, the building was designed so that occupants could not open the doors from the inside.
Personal testimonies reveal the human cost

In his article, Introvigne also describes several testimonies he examined during a visit to South Korea earlier in October.
One young woman was followed by her parents after they discovered that she attended Shincheonji [See editor’s note 2 below]. They forcibly took her from the church and confined her in the family home for three days. During that time, she was reportedly insulted, threatened, deprived of sleep, and subjected to intensive conversion instruction. Her father threatened her with a knife, while her mother forcibly cut her hair.
Another woman was pressured to leave her rented accommodation and return to her parents’ home. Her mother allegedly struck her legs with a pole taken from a clothes rack.
The family demanded that she pay them monthly for the rest of her mother’s life if she wished to continue attending Shincheonji [See editor’s note 2 below]. They also demanded that she sign financial documents, report her daily movements, and install an application allowing them to track her location in real time.
In another case, a male believer was threatened with a knife and told that his ankles would be broken unless he left Shincheonji [See editor’s note 2 below]. His family had also hired a lawyer and presented him with documents intended to change his family register and make him relinquish a gift of shares.
Other believers reported economic boycotts organized by local churches and exclusion from professional associations.
A changing political climate
Introvigne believes that the political atmosphere has contributed to the renewed confidence of anti-cult activists.
Following the assassination of former Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe (安倍晋三) in July 2022, Japan launched an intense campaign against the Family Federation, eventually resulting in its dissolution order.

In South Korea, the government of President Lee Jae-myung (이재명) has also pursued action against groups described as “heretical cults”. This campaign led to the arrests of Family Federation leader Hak Ja Han (한학자) in September 2025 and Shincheonji Chairman Lee Man-hee in June 2026.
According to Introvigne, pastors who had become more cautious following the Gu Ji-in (구지인) tragedy may now believe that the authorities are more sympathetic to their activities.
A further incident reported by a regional Korean newspaper on 14th October illustrates the difficulties involved. Police located an adult woman and three members of her family living together in a villa, apparently isolated from the outside world for approximately a week while the family attempted to make her change her religious activities.
The woman told police that she was not being confined and did not want anyone punished. However, officers indicated that they would continue monitoring the situation.
For Introvigne, this illustrates a central problem: people subjected to pressure by their own families may be reluctant or unable to speak freely while still under their control.
The renewed reports raise serious questions about the protection of religious freedom in South Korea. The issue also leads to a more troubling question: who is organizing, training, and supporting the people carrying out these coercive faith-breaking [See editor’s note 1 below] activities?
As Introvigne’s investigation suggests, the answer leads to a network extending beyond South Korea’s borders.
Source: Based on Massimo Introvigne, “Deprogramming Returns: The Korea-Japan-China Axis of Evil in Action”, Bitter Winter, 30th October 2026.
Continued in part 2: Convicted Pastor Leads Faith-Breaking Network
See part 3: Controversial Korea-Japan Faith-Breaking Ties
See also From Media Label to Religious Persecution
Text: Knut Holdhus, editor
Featured image above: Collage depicting dark practice of faith-breaking (deprogramming) returning to South Korea. Illustration: ChatGPT, 1st November 2026.
[Editor’s note 1: Coercive faith-breaking (“deprogramming”) in Japan refers to the practice of coercively attempting to separate individuals from their religious affiliations or beliefs, typically through intervention by family members, professional faith-breakers (deprogrammers) or organizations hostile to new religious movements (NRMs). This phenomenon often targets members of such movements, e.g. relatively large faiths like the Family Federation or Jehovah’s Witnesses, but also smaller groups like Happy Science (Kōfuku no Kagaku) and other newer religious movements.

However, also Soka Gakkai, a Buddhist-based lay organization with more than 8 million Japanese members, and affiliated with Nichiren Buddhism, has occasionally been subject to faith-breaking attempts.
The practice gained attention in the latter half of the 20th century, particularly in the 1980s and 1990s. Parents or concerned family members often hired faith-breakers who taught them how to abduct and forcibly detain believers. Almost all such cases involved confining the individual believer and cutting him or her off from the religious community. During the confinement, the believer was subjected to intense questioning or indoctrination designed to break his or her faith. The aim was to “rescue” the person from what the family often had been tricked by faith-breakers or lawyers to regard as harmful influence from the religious organization.
Critics of forced de-conversion argue that it violates fundamental human rights, including freedom of thought, religion, and association. Reports of psychological trauma and accusations of unlawful detention have sparked debates over its ethical and legal implications. In response, some religious groups, particularly NRMs, have lobbied for greater protections against such practices.
Japanese courts have been inconsistent in addressing cases of coercive faith-breaking. While some verdicts have condemned the practice as illegal detention, others have been more lenient, citing family concerns about “mental health” or alleged “exploitation” as mitigating factors.]
[Editor’s note 2: Shincheonji, officially known as Shincheonji Church of Jesus, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony, is a new religious movement founded in South Korea in 1984 by Lee Man-hee (이만희), who claims to be the promised pastor mentioned in the Bible’s Book of Revelation.
Shincheonji teaches that the Book of Revelation is being fulfilled through its church and that Lee Man-hee (이만희) has received divine revelation to interpret it. He teaches that South Korea is the location where the prophecies of the Book of Revelation are actively playing out in real-time, making it the epicenter of the final harvest. Shincheonji focuses on filling the literal 144,000 slots of the 12 Tribes mentioned in Revelation. Once this number of truly sealed, flawless believers is completed, they believe they will rule as kings and priests over the rest of humanity.]
[Editor’s note 3: The World Mission Society Church of God (WMSCOG) is a South Korean Christian movement founded in 1964 by Ahn Sahng-hong (안상홍 – 1918–1985). Its distinctive teachings include the belief that Ahn Sahng-hong (안상홍) was Christ returned to Earth and that God exists as both God the Father and God the Mother. The church believes that Zahng Gil-jah (장길자, born 1943) is the literal embodiment of God the Mother. The church emphasizes the Bible, observance of the Saturday Sabbath and biblical festivals, particularly Passover, which it considers essential to salvation. Headquartered in South Korea, it has expanded internationally, establishing congregations in numerous countries. Its members also participate in volunteer activities, including environmental projects and community service.]
[Editor’s note 4: The Christian Gospel Mission (CGM), also known as Providence or JMS (Jesus Morning Star), is a South Korean Christian new religious movement founded by Jung Myung-seok (정명석 – also romanized as Jeong Myeong-seok) in the late 1970s. It emphasizes Bible study, personal spiritual development and a distinctive interpretation of Christian scripture, often taught through a series of 30 lessons. Jung has been regarded by followers as a specially chosen messianic figure. The movement has expanded internationally, particularly among young people and university students. It has attracted considerable controversy because of serious sexual abuse allegations against its founder, who was sentenced to 17 years in prison by South Korea’s Supreme Court in January 2025.]
Related to dark practice returning: Mother Han: The Dangers of Guilt by Position
Related to dark practice returning: Mother Han: Beyond One Trial – the Wider Stakes
Related to dark practice returning: At Issue: Religions Taking Reality Seriously
Also related to dark practice returning: Religion Between Engagement and Withdrawal
Also related to dark practice returning: State Failure and Non-State Peace Projects
More, related to dark practice returning: Detention: Harsh Cell Conditions Spark Outcry
And more, related to dark practice returning: Official Statement on Recent Media Coverage
Also related to dark practice returning: Defense Challenges Core Claims of Indictment
And also related to dark practice returning: Unificationism Emerging as a World Religion
More, related to dark practice returning: Decline of Family Values Creates Social Crisis
And more, related to dark practice returning: Unificationism, Industry, and Cold War Survival
And more, related to dark practice returning: Movement Promoting Family as National Solution
Yet more, related to dark practice returning: “Church Closure” Risks in South Korea’s New Bill
Still more, related to dark practice returning: Mother Han Nominated for Nobel Peace Prize 2026
Also related to dark practice returning: Democratic Party’s Assault on Family Federation
And even more, related to dark practice returning: Mother Han (82) in Poor Health in Damp, Cold Cell
And still more, related to dark practice returning: Korean Crisis: “True Democracy Must Serve Heaven”
And yet more, related to dark practice returning: Faith Leaders Protest State Assault on Religion
And more, related to dark practice returning: Trump Raises Alarm Over Church Raids in Korea
Even more, related to dark practice returning: Mike Pompeo Calls Probe of Co-Founder “Lawfare”
Still more, related to dark practice returning: Korean Faith Crackdown: USA Urged to Confront It
Yet more, related to dark practice returning: Korean Bribery Scandal: Media Clears Federation
Related to dark practice returning: Lawfare: State Uses Legal System in War on Faith
More, related to dark practice returning: Shocked Author: “Japan Ignores Basics of Justice”
Still more, related to dark practice returningr: Legal Inconsistencies A Blow to Democracy
Even more, related to dark practice returning: Japan: Court Accused of Using Speculation
Also related to dark practice returning: MEXT’s Legal Spin and “Dissolution at All Costs”
Also related to dark practice returning: UN Report: Japan’s Lawfare Against Faith Minority
And also related to dark practice returning: Protesting No Transparency in Closed-Door Trial







