New Law Manufacturing “Victims”, Dividing Families

Expert on international human rights shocked by outrageous new anti-religious Japanese law that manufactures “victims” entitled to go to court to obtain large compensation for donations made years, even decades earlier

Tokyo, 4th February 2025 – Published as an article in the Japanese newspaper Sekai Nippo. Republished with permission. Translated from Japanese. Original article. 

[Series] Request for Dissolution Order of the Family Federation – Suspicions of Fabricated Statements by the Ministry of Education

Part 1 of interview with an expert: New Law Instead Leads to Family Division

International Human Rights Lawyer Patricia Duval

by the Religious Freedom Investigative Team of the editorial department of Sekai Nippo

See part 2 of interview

It has been reported that the statement submitted by Japan’s Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT) to the Tokyo District Court as evidence in its request for a dissolution order against the Family Federation for World Peace and Unification (formerly the Unification Church) contained fabricated testimonies. Amid such reports, French international human rights lawyer Patricia Duval, who is currently visiting Japan, provided her insights.

Duval also directly met with Miyuki Kawaguchi (pseudonym), who was previously interviewed by our newspaper on 21st January. Kawaguchi had spoken with her elderly mother, who had signed the MEXT statement, and the mother denied ever having said what was written in the document.

Q: What was your impression after meeting face-to-face with Miyuki Kawaguchi, who also spoke to our newspaper and Kyodo News?

I heard her testimony directly. As reported, it was the mother who introduced her daughter to the church, and the two had lived a life of faith together for over 30 years.

However, the MEXT statement, which the mother supposedly signed, claimed that she had been coerced by her daughter into making donations long ago, and that she wished for the dissolution of the Family Federation.

Originally, Kawaguchi’s brother did not entirely share the faith of his mother and sister, but he also never actively opposed it. However, following the assassination of former Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, the media became flooded with one-sided criticism of the Family Federation. This drastically changed his stance.

Following MEXT’s request for a dissolution order, a new law called the Special Act on Relief for Victims of Certain Unlawful Acts was enacted at the end of the previous year. This law, effectively targeting the Family Federation, allows individuals to more easily participate in collective negotiations for donation-related damages with government support.

It seems that the brother consulted Houterasu (Japan Legal Support Center), and MEXT later contacted their mother. After a lengthy interview, a statement was prepared.

What a shocking development! This new law has instead caused division within this family. The donations that the mother once made out of her faith were reframed – through MEXT’s intervention – as coerced contributions made under her daughter’s influence.

Furthermore, the suspicion that MEXT fabricated the testimony surfaced when a Kyodo News report was published by Sankei Shimbun. After this, the woman’s sons reportedly visited her and said, “At least read the first page of the statement.” They emphasized that it contained her handwritten signature, seemingly hoping for a selective interpretation of the facts. However, doubts deepened that the statement had been submitted without the mother fully verifying its contents.

As a result, the daughter was forced to submit a “counter-statement” to the Tokyo District Court through the Family Federation, testifying to the true facts. The judge must now compare the two statements and consider the new family conflict caused by the new law.

In reality, the mother, who is over 90 years old, is caught in the middle of a conflict between her sons and her daughter. Should she be forced to abandon her faith? No, the government should remain neutral, respecting both the rights of believers and non-believers. In fact, the mother’s freedom of religion should be protected.

The government likely intended to help victims when it enacted the new law, but in practice, it has become an authority that rewrites the past lives of elderly individuals. Instead of protecting the mother, it has brought her new suffering in her final years.

The New Law Manufactures “Victims”

Q: Isn’t it ironic that the new law, rather than providing relief, is instead creating tragedies in believers’ families?

As seen in the Kawaguchi case, the media’s relentless focus on criticizing the Family Federation has caused significant harm to society. In an environment where there is little tolerance for new religious movements, believers’ past donations – made as religious acts – have now been reframed as cases of “financial fraud”, fostering resentment among their relatives.

With the enactment of the Special Act on Relief for Victims of Certain Unlawful Acts, which covers litigation costs for claimants, Ms. Kawaguchi’s brother decided to pursue a refund claim. This government system has incited families into legal action, transforming past events into “victimization” retroactively. Shockingly, donations made on average 20 years ago – and in some cases up to 60 years ago – are now being reported as “damages”.

During my visit to Japan, I was able to directly confirm how this new law is being applied alongside the Tokyo District Court’s hearings on MEXT’s dissolution order request.

The total amount of claims in the collective lawsuits coordinated by the National Lawyers Network against the Unification Church has now reached 5 billion yen (approximately $33 million). In the future, additional claims could be created at any time. This systematic approach is effectively pushing the Family Federation toward financial collapse.

See part 2 of interview

Featured image above: Patricia Duval – Member of the Paris Bar Association, specializing in international human rights law. She obtained a degree in public law from the Sorbonne University in France. She has defended the rights of religious minorities and believers both in France and internationally, including in international organizations such as the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), the Council of Europe (CoE), the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), the European Union (EU), and the United Nations. She has also published numerous academic papers on religion and freedom of belief. Photo: Sekai Nippo

Related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Japan’s New Laws to Curb New Religious Movements

Also related to new law manufacturing “victims”: New Law Designed to Bankrupt Family Federation

Also related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Terms from Consumer Law Used to Rob Faith

And also related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Maverick Minister Lets “3 Foxes in the Henhouse”

More, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Journalist Reveals Ugly Leftwing Conspiracy

And more, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Militant Lawyers Dictate Government Policy

And more, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Courts Using Debunked Concepts Against Minority

Also related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Dissolution Case: Wild Claims, Illegal Actions

Also related to new law manufacturing “victims”: 2nd-Generation Members Protesting Persecution

Also related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Inhuman Government-Supported Mass Deprogramming

And also related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Bias: No Right to Respond for Religious Minority

More, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Collusion to Rob Minority of Its Rights

And more, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: State and Media Creating “Today’s Non-Citizens”

Still more, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Japan Criticized for Glaring Rights Violations

Even more, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Two European Scholars Warning Japan

And yet more, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Japan Censured at Religious Freedom Event

And still more, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Lawyer Exposes Dirty Leftwing Plot

And even more, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Inhuman Government-Supported Mass Deprogramming

And still more, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Malicious One-Sided Government Source Selection

More, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Government’s Foul Play Pointed Out

More, related to new law manufacturing “victims”: Kishida Has Opened Can of Worms